3 comparison of industrial fieldbus systems, Comparison of industrial fieldbus systems, Preface – Lenze EMF2113IB User Manual

Page 7: Show/hide bookmarks

Advertising
background image

Comparison of industrial fieldbus systems

1

Preface

1.3

L

1.3-1

EDSIBS-1.0-06/2003

1.3

Comparison of industrial fieldbus systems

CAN / CANOpen

DeviceNet

PROFIBUS-DP

AS-i

INTERBUS

INTERBUS loop

LON

Topology

Line with termination
resistors

Line with termination
resistors

Line with termination
resistors

Line, tree, ring
(possible)

Ring

Ring

Line (2 wire) or any
other

Bus management

Multi master

Single master

Single master

Single master

Single master

Only together with
INTERBUS-S; single
master (bus terminal)

Multi master

Max. number of
devices (master

and slaves)

64

64

124 (4 segments, 3
repeaters),
max. 32 per segment

124 sensors/actuators
1 master

512 slaves,
1 master

32 slaves

32385 devices
distributed to 255
subnetworks with 127
devices each

Max. distance
between devices

without repeater

Depending on the baud
rate
1 km (50 kBit/s)
25 m (1 MBit/s)

100 m (500 kBit/s)
250 m (250 kBit/s)
500 m (125 kBit/s)

1,2 km (93.75 kBit/s)
100 m (12 MBit/s)

100 m

1.5 m (local bus)
400 m (remote bus)
2.5 km (optical fibre)

10 m (max. 100 m cable
length without repeater)

2 km at 78 kBit/s
(twisted pair),
6.1 km at 5.48 kBit/s
(optical fibre plastics)

Max. distance
between devices

with repeater

General length reduction
Depending on the
repeater used

not specified

10 km (93.75 kBit/s)

300 m (2 repeaters)

13 km (remote bus),
100 km (optical fibre)

No repeater required

Almost any
Expandable by
subnetworks (without
repeaters)

Transfer medium

Shielded, twisted pair
cable

Shielded, twisted pair
cable

Shielded, twisted pair
cable

Unshielded and
untwisted flat pair cable

Shielded, twisted 5-wire
cable
Optical fibre, infrared

Unshielded, twisted pair
cable

Unshielded and
untwisted pair cable
Radio, optical fibre,
power line

Auxiliary energy
supply via bus

cable

Possible via additional
wires in the bus cable

Possible via additional
wires in the bus cable

Possible via additional
wires in the bus cable

Current supply via data
cable (2 to 8 A)

separately, group via
bus terminal (remote
bus)

Current supply via data
cable (approx. 1.5 A)

Possible via additional
wires in the bus cable

Baud rate

10 kBit/s - 1 MBit/s

125 kBit/s,
250 kBit/s,
500 kBit/s

9.6 kBit/s - 12 MBit/s

167 kBit/s

500 kBit/s or 2 MBit/s

500 kBit/s

78 kBit/s - 1.25 MBit/s

Update time
typical (e.g. 8

devices, 4 bytes

user data)

approx. 1,32 ms at
1 MBit/s (high priority)

approx. 2.64 ms at 500
kBit/s (high priority)

approx. 2.5 ms at 500
kBit/s

typically 5 ms (every 4
bits)

at least 2 ms (process
data)

at least 2 ms (process
data)

approx. 70 ms

Telegram length
(user data)

0 to 8 bytes

0 to 8 bytes

0 to 246 bytes

4 bits

1 to 64 bytes data;
up to 246 bytes
parameters

1 to 64 bytes data;
up to 246 bytes
parameters

1 to 228 bytes data;
typically approx. 11
bytes

Telegram length
(total)

106 bits at 8 bytes user
data

106 bits at 8 bytes user
data

user data +
6 to 11 bytes

21 bits, of which:
14 bits master, 7 bits
slave

user data +
6 bytes

user data +
6 bytes

max. 255 bytes,
user data + 27 bytes

Bus access
methods

CSMA/CA message
oriented

CSMA/CA message
oriented

Cyclic polling

Cyclic polling

Time grid / distributed
shift register

Time grid / distributed
shift register

Modified CSMA/CD

Lenze communication modules for LENZE basic devices

9300 Servo
Inverter and

Servo PLC

on board (only parts of
CANopen)
CANopen 2175
(pluggable)

2175 (pluggable)

2133 (pluggable)

not available

2111 and 2113 (both
pluggable)

2112 (pluggable)

2141 (pluggable)

8200 vector
frequency

inverter

Function module
System bus (only parts
of CANopen)
E82ZAFCC010
E82ZAFCC100 or
E82ZAFCC210
or pluggable 2175
(CANopen)
2171, 2172 (parts of
CANopen)

Function module (in
preparation)
Pluggable 2175

Function module
E82ZAFPC010 or 2133
(pluggable)

E82ZAFFC010 function
module

Function module
E82ZAFIC010 (can be
integrated) or 2111 or
2113 (both pluggable)

2112 (pluggable)

2141 (pluggable)

Frequency
inverter 8200

motec

Function module
System bus (only parts
of CANopen)
E82ZAFCC001

(in preparation)

Function module
E82ZAFPC001

Function module
E82ZAFFC001

Function module
E82ZAFIC001 (can be
integrated)

-

-

Drive PLC

Function module
System bus (only parts
of CANopen)
E82ZAFCC010
or 2175 (pluggable)

2175 (pluggable)

2133 (pluggable)

-

2111 and 2113 (both
pluggable)

2112 (pluggable)

2141 (pluggable)

starttec

Function module
System bus (only parts
of CANopen)
E82ZAFCC001

(in preparation)

Function module
E82ZAFPC001

Can be integrated into
the basic device as
variant

Function module
E82ZAFIC001 (can be
integrated)

-

-

Show/Hide Bookmarks

Advertising